Thursday, April 18, 2024

Does Refinancing Your Mortgage Hurt Your Credit Score

Don't Miss

Your Lender Will Check Your Credit Report

Does Refinancing a Loan Hurt Your Credit Score?

If you apply for a refinance loan, your lender will check your and your credit report. Having a lender review your credit information will trigger a hard inquiry. New credit inquiries show up on your credit report and account for 10% of your FICO credit score. Each new inquiry for credit can knock a few points off your credit score.

Generally, if youre rate shopping within a small window of time , multiple loan applications will show up as a single inquiry on your credit report. On the other hand, if you spend several months applying for different refinance loans multiple inquiries will appear on your credit report. Your credit score may drop significantly, meaning that itll be harder to qualify for a loan or lock in the best rates.

When Should I Refinance My Mortgage

There are a lot of factors to think through when Consider market trends , as well as your personal financial health . Its a good idea to use a mortgage refinance calculator to figure out your break-even point after accounting for refinancing expenses.

You also need to know how refinancing differs from other mortgage options like loan modification and second mortgages. The major difference between a refinance and a loan modification is that refinancing gives you a new mortgage while modification changes your current terms.

The new mortgage you get from refinancing replaces the existing one, an important distinction between getting a second mortgage and refinancing. Review what works best for you before deciding what to do.

Its important to note that a modification should only be considered if you cant qualify for a refinance and you need long-term payment relief. Modification typically has a major negative impact on your credit score.

If youre interested in lowering your monthly payment, a mortgage recast is a straightforward option. It involves making a significant lump-sum payment on your principal so your lender can reamortize the balance.

How Refinancing A Mortgage Can Affect Your Credit

When youre interested in reducing your mortgage rate and lowering your monthly mortgage payments, refinancing may solve some of your problems. While youre going through the process of refinancing, you may forget to consider how it could affect your credit score. Here are a few things youll need to take into account before setting out to get a better deal on your home loan.

Recommended Reading: Does Charles Schwab Offer Mortgages

When Should You Refinance Your Home

Carefully consider your current financial situation. If youre worried about rising interest rates, now might be the time to start shopping around to lock in a rate before the situation changes.

Additionally, its important to consider your other financial goals. Heck suggests planning your loans in a way that reduces their impact on each other. For example, you might try to avoid getting a new car loan at the same time youre refinancing your mortgage. Space out your loans so they have less of an impact on each other.

If you do plan to apply for new financing, like an auto loan or mortgage, you might want to consider holding off on your refinance until after you close on those new loans, Black agrees. Otherwise, a potential credit score drop from refinancing might cause you problems.

Tips On How To Prepare For Refinancing Your Home

Does Refinancing a Loan Affect Credit Scores?

The following are good things to keep in mind when getting ready for a refinance:

Check your credit history. You can do this through either of the major credit bureaus or for free through your credit card issuer or your bank.

Clean up errors. There is a chance that your credit report is lower than it ought to be due to derogatory or false marks. You can dispute these by contacting a credit bureau.

Get pre-qualified. Source the best offer for you by shopping around with multiple lenders.

Organize your paperwork. Prior to finishing your application, prepare your financial documents and tax forms.

Complete application. This step can be completed after you have decided on a lender who offers the best repayment terms and interest rate for you.

Keep paying your current loan. The process of repaying your current loan is incomplete until your new refinancing lender tells you so.

Read Also: What Does Mortgage Forbearance Mean

Tips To Preserve Your Credit Score When You Refinance

Smart homeowners compare rates from several different lenders when theyre refinancing. If you want six quotes, does that mean your credit score takes six hits?

Luckily, no getting multiple rate quotes wont ding your score multiple times. FICO says its score allows for rate shopping.

But, you have to be smart about how you shop to protect your score and that means getting all your quotes within a few weeks at most.

Comparison shop during a focused period

To protect your credit score when you refinance, you have to all your rate-shopping applications within a focused period. If you take several months to apply for quotes, each may be seen as a separate hard inquiry.

For FICO, a focused period typically means getting your rate quotes within 30 days.

More recent versions of the FICO scoring model allow a 45-day period for rate shopping. But dont take chances. Many lenders use older versions of FICO to calculate your score.

So, provided you make all your rate-shopping applications within a single 30-day timeframe, your score should take just one standard hit of around five points or less the same as someone who doesnt shop around.

Other steps to protect your credit

Experian raises an important point for refinancing homeowners: You need to be absolutely sure you make every payment on your original mortgage on time.

Not all mortgage lenders are paragons of efficiency. And if your new one pays just a day late, your credit score will likely be dinged by a late payment.

Does Refinancing Hurt Your Credit Score

However, the credit hits from applying for and opening a refinance loan are very small often less than five points, according to FICO.

The savings youre likely to see from refinancing should far outweigh any negative impact on your credit. So dont let that be a concern when you apply.

In this article

You May Like: How Is Home Mortgage Interest Calculated

When Refinancing Isnt Such A Good Idea

While refinancing a loan can be a great option, its important to understand whether its right for you. Before applying to refinance your loans, see if you fit any of the below criteria to determine if refinancing is a smart move for you.

  • You have federal loans and may lose some income: During COVID-19, the government has put together federal loan relief programs. However, if you refinance loans, you may become ineligible for these programs.
  • You are applying for loan forgiveness: For those who are repaying student loans, its important to note that if the student loans are refinanced, they lose eligibility for federal loan forgiveness.
  • Youve declared bankruptcy: Although its still possible to refinance your loans after declaring bankruptcy, its significantly more difficult. Its common for lenders to require a period of four to 10 years since declaring bankruptcy to lend to you.

Its best to avoid refinancing unsecured debt with secured debt, according to Rick Orford, Personal Finance Expert and Author of The Financially Independent Millennial. For example, your mortgage company might offer you the ability to refinance your home or apply for a home equity line of credit to consolidate credit cards, car loans, etc, Orford told us. If you take this route and end up in a tight spot, your home will be at risk, and youll potentially lose even more. Only refinance when you have a plan in place.

What Is Refinancing And Why Would I Want To Do It

Do Mortgage Inquiries Hurt Your Credit Score?

Refinancing is an option for homeowners and real estate investors to take advantage of lower interest rates or different loan terms – known as a “lower pricing point” – relative to their original, fixed-rate home loans.

A refinanced mortgage may allow a homeowner to unlock the equity that they were unable to fully access with the higher interest rate on their original mortgage, or it may be linked with other financial matters such as consolidating multiple lines of credit into one. A new lender will do an appraisal of your property in exchange for debt reduction or cash upfront.

Should you choose this route, make sure your new lender is reputable and in the business for years and someone whom you can trust with all your finances.

Recommended Reading: What Is The Mortgage Rate At The Moment

When To Refinance A Mortgage

The best time to refinance a mortgage is when it saves you money or decreases your monthly payments. Under the right market conditions, refinancing can help you save interest over the long run, but it also can help you eliminate a Federal Housing Administration loan that comes with high mortgage insurance premiums. Likewise, if you need to tap into your home equity, refinancing your mortgage is a great way to do so.

Keep in mind, however, that refinancing a mortgage does come with closing costs, including an origination fee, appraisal costs, title insurance and credit reporting fees. These costs often add up to between 2% and 6% of the total loan amount.

Whats more, refinancing a mortgage typically involves extending payments out over a longer period of time. While this lowers the amount you pay each month, it means interest will accrue for longer. If youre considering a mortgage refinancing, use a mortgage refinance calculator to determine the break-even point.

If youre unsure of whether now is a good time to refinance your mortgage, work with some of the best mortgage refinance lenders to see how much you could save.

Is It Important To Compare Mortgage Rates

Comparing mortgage rates is one way to save money on your home loan. If you accept the first offer you see, you may regret it later. With so much competition in the lending industry today, you can usually find a lower rate if you do a little price comparison.

The easiest way to find low rates is to shop around. This is really easy in todays internet-driven world. There are loan calculators, comparison tools, lender portals, and more all designed to help you line up offers to see which is giving you the right deal.

You May Like: How To Report To A Credit Bureau Landlord

Don’t Miss: How Long Does A Mortgage Take

Consolidating Your Debt Consolidating Your Debt With A Cash

When determining whether to refinance your loans or not, its important to take into account the pros and cons of refinancing for your situation. Although refinancing can hurt your credit for a few months, if youre smart about it, you can minimize the impact on your credit score while pursuing lower interest rates and less expensive monthly costs.

If youre looking to repair your credit, it can be tough to know where to start. From the time you spend understanding your score to figuring out your credit history, credit repair is something you want to get right on the first trywhich is why many people are turning to our team for help. Check us out and learn more about the services we offer to help you repair your credit today.

It Results In Multiple ‘hard’ Inquiries

Does Refinancing Hurt Your Credit Score

Each time you apply for a new loan, your lender will request your credit history from one of the major credit bureaus, Equifax or TransUnion.

This is called a hard inquiry, and each one that’s made will lower your credit score several points. They typically stay on your report for 24 months.

Most people like to shop around for rates and compare quotes to get the best deal.

It’s fine to check the rates. The trouble comes when you actually apply for multiple mortgages.

Don’t Miss: When Does It Make Sense To Refinance Mortgage

Dont Refinance If Its Not Really A Better Deal

Sometimes a refinance only looks like a better deal. For instance, lets say you have a $500 credit card balance at 10% interest. You can pay it off in a couple of months, but you get a 0% APR introductory deal. Sure, you wont save much interest with the deal, but youll save some, right?

Not so fast! These deals often charge a balance transfer fee. Its often a percentage of the balance, with a $5 minimum. Youre paying about $4 per month in interest on that card now. If youre going to pay it off within a month or two, you may actually pay more in the balance transfer fee than youll pay in interest while waiting to pay it off!

The same goes for refinancing your home, although the break-even calculation gets a lot more complicated. Generally, home refinancing includes many of the same closing costs as buying a home. So you cant just get into a better interest rate for free. In fact, you could have to front a few grand to refinance.

If youre planning to stay in your home for a while, the savings on interest will likely be worth it. Even a percentage point or two makes a big difference over the life of such a large loan.

But what if you plan to sell your home within the next five years? In this case, refinancing may not be worth the money or effort.

Need help doing the math to see whether a refinance is worthwhile? Check out this calculator to help you make the calculations:

A Lower Rate And A Lower Credit Score Temporarily

When we started shopping around for rates on a new mortgage its best to get a few quotes so you know your options we knew that the creditors would check our credit reports. We knew that this would show up as a hard inquiry on our reports, which would likely ding our credit scores by a few points.

We learned that even if a few different creditors pull your reports while youre interest rate shopping, multiple inquiries while rate shopping over a short time frame will usually be lumped together into just one inquiry. That way, the effects on your score are minimized.

After locking in a low rate and signing a fat stack of papers, we were the proud owners of a brand-new mortgage. We traded our 30-year mortgage for a 15-year loan at a much lower interest rate, and successfully slashed the number of years we’ll be making payments. I was ecstatic about the money wed save. But I wasnt quite as excited about what happened to my credit score.

About a month after closing, I noticed that my FICO score dropped more than 30 points. My VantageScore fell 13 points. These two main credit scoring models consider most of the same factors when calculating your credit score but weigh them a bit differently. The things that affect your scores are:

Unfortunately, when you refinance, the information about how much of your previous loan you had paid off doesnt carry over. You also likely will lower your overall age of accounts by replacing an older account with a brand-new one.

Read Also: What Is The Minimum Down Payment Required For A Mortgage

How Much Does A Credit Pull Really Hurt

When youre in the market for a mortgage, its best to shop around to find the best rates or get better lender fees. But because this process typically involves multiple lenders checking your credit score, many buyers are concerned these credit inquiries or often referred to as credit pulls will hurt their score, leaving them less inclined to shop around. But the good news is as long as you follow a few guidelines, you can shop around for mortgages without doing too much damage to your credit.

Modifying An Existing Home Loan

Does refinancing hurt your credit?

Modifying a loan may have less of an effect on your credit score, either way, than refinancing the debt with a new lender or loan. Thats because modification generally wont change your balance or the accounts opening date.

When you modify a loan with the same lender, you generally just get better terms than you have right now. For instance, if your credit score is significantly better than it was 10 years ago when you bought your home, you may be able to approach your lender to ask for a better interest rate.

This loan modification may affect your score slightly, since the lender will pull a credit report to check your creditworthiness. But the overall effect of this move will likely be slight and short-lived.

Recommended Reading: What Is The Interest Rate On A Reverse Mortgage Loan

What Are Todays Mortgage Rates

Although mortgage rates fluctuate daily, 2020 and 2021 were years of record lows for mortgage and refinance rates across the US.

While low average mortgage and refinance rates are a promising sign for a more affordable loan, remember that theyre never a guarantee of the rate a lender will offer you. Mortgage rates vary by borrower, based on factors like your credit, loan type, and down payment. To get the best rate for you, youll want to gather rates from multiple lenders.

Mortgage type

Too Much Mortgage Refinancing Is Not Good

Refinancing might become problematic for your credit score if you are constantly refinancing or applying for new credit related to your mortgage. While there are certain exceptions, credit rating companies often frown at having your credit score pulled too many times over a short period, and from too many different potential creditors.

In fact, FICO might penalize you for being unable to honor a credit contract or for having too many inquiries on your credit report. Also, every time you refinance, your credit score is pulled, and having too many credit score requests in a relatively short period of time often has a negative impact on your credit score.

Similarly, interest rate shopping for a refinance on your current mortgage can result in multiple credit inquiries in a short period. Fortunately, back in 2009 FICO and other credit scoring systems changed the way multiple inquiries are treated on your credit score for certain kinds of debt, such as mortgages or student loans.

If you are going to shop around, FICO recommends submitting all of your applications within a 30- to 45-day period. In its newest scoring model, even if you do not end up accepting a new loan, FICO treats all of your inquiries during that period as just one credit pull, minimizing the impact on your score. However, FICO acknowledges that some lenders still choose to use older FICO scoring models, so some people still prefer to limit their inquiries to a 14-day period.

Also Check: How To Get Out Of A Westgate Timeshare Mortgage

More articles

Popular Articles